The NFL Duel: A Comparative Analysis of Jaguars QB Trevor Lawrence and Justin Fields

Stats, Madden rating, MVP race and fantasy projections, is the NFL top 100 accurate? Who comes on top? Trevor Lawrence or Justin Fields?
Jacksonville Jaguars v Dallas Cowboys
Jacksonville Jaguars v Dallas Cowboys / Richard Rodriguez/GettyImages
1 of 5

In the National Football League (NFL) world, few debates exist as contentious as the ongoing comparison between Trevor Lawrence and Justin Fields. There needs to be an in-depth comparison of these two athletes, evaluating their performance on the football field and their impact on the game. 2021 NFL Draft Prospects: Lawrence vs. Fields.

In the 2021 NFL Draft, both Lawrence and Fields were top prospects. Their journey from college football to professional leagues was closely watched, with analysts continually comparing their skills, potential, and performance.

Recently the Black and Teal posted an article stating that Justin Fields is nowhere near Trevor Lawrence. While this felt like an undeniable fact, I felt it needed a little deeper look and evaluation to substantiate these claims. What my analysis found might surprise you.

Lawrence, the first overall pick in the 2021 NFL Draft, was selected by the Jacksonville Jaguars, while Fields, the 11th pick, joined the Chicago Bears. From the onset, these two quarterbacks' careers have been intertwined, with their performance and growth constantly analyzed side by side.

A Surprise in the NFL's Top 100 List

The intrigue around the Lawrence-Fields comparison gained momentum with unveiling of the NFL's Top 100 list for the 2022-23 season. The list revealed a surprising twist: Fields was ranked at No. 86, ten spots ahead of Lawrence, fueling further debates.

Despite the fact that Lawrence leading the Jaguars to the playoffs for the first time since 2017, Fields' highlight reel impressed players around the league more. Fields, known for his game-breaking runs and dual-threat capability, became a fan favorite in 2022, even though the Bears ended the season with the league's worst record.

On the other hand, Lawrence showcased his competence with a stronger roster and coaching staff, nearly defeating the eventual Super Bowl champion, the Kansas City Chiefs, in the Divisional Round.

Despite the satisfaction with their young stars' performance, fans expressed mixed feelings about the quarterbacks' ranking, with Lawrence being outright disrespected at 96 to Fields at 86. Here's how all the numbers look in the essential categories: 2022 performances, fantasy projections, Madden 24 ratings, preseason performance, and MVP projections.