Skip to main content

Robert Hainsey may not get his starting Jaguars job back even if he's healthy

He may get Wally Pipped again.
ByCarlos Sanchez
Jacksonville Jaguars center Robert Hainsey (73) wipes sweat during the first day of minicamp at the Miller Electric Center, Tuesday, June 9, 2026, in Jacksonville, Fla.
Jacksonville Jaguars center Robert Hainsey (73) wipes sweat during the first day of minicamp at the Miller Electric Center, Tuesday, June 9, 2026, in Jacksonville, Fla. | USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect

Aside from needing a new head coach, the Jacksonville Jaguars had roster holes in 2025. Center was among them, and they took care of it when they signed Robert Hainsey to a three-year deal in free agency. At the time, the move made sense.

Hainsey had ample starting experience during his four-year stint with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. On top of that, head coach Liam Coen was his offensive coordinator in 2024. That kind of familiarity was huge to the Jacksonville offensive line. Then again, there was a reason the former Notre Dame Irish was available, to begin with.

The year before he landed in Duval, Hainsey was benched in favor of then-rookie Graham Norton. Fast forward to 2026, and there's a chance he could be Wally-Pipped for the second time in his NFL career.

Why could Robert Hainsey lose his starting job with the Jaguars?

Robert Hainsey has become a key contributor for the Jaguars, making 24 starts at center dating back to 2025. On top of that, he's been named team captain two years in a row, which goes to show just how highly his teammates think of him.

However, Hainsey just suffered a knee injury that could sideline him for a handful of weeks. The good news is that the injury isn't serious enough to sideline him the rest of the year. That said, he may not get his job back.

For as long as Hainsey is out, Jonah Monheim will fill in for him at center. A seventh-round pick in 2025, Monheim has flashed potential and held the fort when Hainsey left the win over the Tennessee Titans in Week 11, giving up no sacks and no pressures on 44 offensive snaps.

Both Liam Coen and Trevor Lawrence have heaped praise on Monheim. Of course, the sophomore out of USC needs to show that he can deliver on a full-time basis. Jacksonville may want to keep him at center permanently.

You may also like: Free agent check-in: Jordan Davis & Jessie Bates make things interesting

Why would the Jaguars roll with Jonah Monehim the rest of the season?

The Jaguars may want to evaluate Jonah Monheim and see what they have at center for a key reason. Jacksonville is already in the red for 2027 and will need to shed $20.1 million in space just to get under the cap. The good news is that the team's brass can easily create a substantial amount of cap room with a handful of contract restructures and a few roster cuts. On the other hand, that doesn't bode well for Robert Hainsey and other veterans.

Hainsey is slated to count $9.8 million against the cap next year, but releasing him would free up $3.9 million with $5.8 million in dead money. If Jonah Monheim plays well, he'll be among the first players to get the boot. Sure, the Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania native is a prominent locker room presence and a pretty good player, but his contract makes him a prime candidate to get the boot.

Maybe the Jaguars can keep Robert Hainsey if they rework his deal, but releasing him could be a more realistic possibility. Jonah Monheim could make the decision easier if he plays well.

Add us as a preferred source on Google