Skip to main content

ESPN analyst completely missed the point of Jaguars' bold trade approach

Some analyts are losing sight of the ultimate goal.
ByCarlos Sanchez
Oct 18, 2026; London, United Kingdom; Jacksonville Jaguars general manager James Gladstone (right) and executive vice president of football operations Tony Boselli during the 2026 NFL London Games against the Houston Texans at Wembley Stadium.
Oct 18, 2026; London, United Kingdom; Jacksonville Jaguars general manager James Gladstone (right) and executive vice president of football operations Tony Boselli during the 2026 NFL London Games against the Houston Texans at Wembley Stadium. | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Jacksonville Jaguars were a pretty good team that generated plenty of hype following their 5-2 start. However, they didn't want to settle for good, so general manager James Gladstone took a wild swing at the trade deadline, acquiring defensive tackle Davon Godchaux, safety Jessie Bates III, and defensive tackle Jordan Davis.

The Jags' aggressive approach turned heads, as they made it clear that they're setting their sights on the Super Bowl. On the other hand, Gladstone caught heat for overpaying for Davis and Bates. What critics miss is that the Jags were going to find bargains at the deadline, and it won't matter how much they paid if they ended up going all the way.

Nevertheless, an ESPN analyst believes that even if Jacksonville ultimately wins the Super Bowl, that won't be enough to justify the price of their trades.

Seth Walder says winning the Super Bowl won't be enough to justify the Jaguars' trades

Seth Walder made an appearance on the Bill Barnwell Show and stated that the Jaguars overpaid for Jessie Bates III and Jordan Davis, pointing out that they're not getting nearly enough value for the price they paid.

"This is a bad trade, right? You don't get anywhere near the value that you're returning. I completely agree. They should be going, they should be pushing chips in. They should be going for it," Walder said (the exchange starts at the 8:17 mark). "That's like why I approve of the Jesse Bates deal. And by the way, they may win the Super Bowl here, that will not exonerate this trade. Otherwise, every deal is 'what if you trade four Jordan picks for Jordan Davis' and you win the Super Bowl, is that good?"

Walder continued, "But the other thing is the alternatives. If you needed to trade those picks for this a player this year then you could have gotten a better a good a better player. I mean, and every other team should have been, should be right now, today, kicking themselves. Why were we not on the phone with James Gladstone all day, going through our entire roster and seeing which player he was going to give an absurd price to?"

What Walder fails to grasp is that it takes two to tango, and Jacksonville simply didn't have carte blanche. James Gladstone had to work the phones to find who was available and what was needed to get a deal done.

For his part, Barnwell stated that he liked that the Jags were aggressive but isn't enthused about the trades they made.

"I mean, this is obviously a very aggressive move. I think it's the nicest way we can put it in front of the Jacksonville Jaguars. I think they're a good team. I think they're a championship-caliber team. I think from that perspective, I have no issue with them trading picks away for players right now. I just don't think this was the right picks for the right player," Barnwell said.

Walder originally gave the Jordan Davis trade an F, so it looks like he hasn't changed his stance. If anything, he's doubling down.

You may also like: What happened the last time the Jags started a season 7-2?

Why Seth Walder lost the plot on the Jaguars making a splash for Jordan Davis

The Jaguars gave up premium compensation to acquire a proven commodity in Jordan Davis. It's hard to tell what they would've done with the 2027 first-round pick and the 2028 second-round selection they sent to the Philadelphia Eagles, but the Jags knew they got a run stuffer who can help them address the void left by DaVon Hamilton's season-ending quad injury.

Finding a player who will not only replace Hamilton but also be an upgrade wasn't going to come cheap. And if Davis ends up being the piece Jacksonville needed, it will all be worth it. Based on his comments, Seth Walder is more interested in finding value on paper and hoarding assets.

The good news is that James Gladstone isn't thinking about the value of unknown commodities. Sure, he could have acquired a Pro Bowl player with one of the two picks he gave up for Davis (the proverbial mystery box) but instead chose to go and get one now.

Simply put, the Jaguars know the cost of doing business and paid the price to increase their odds of being showered in confetti come February. If they pull it off, though, you can bet Seth Walder will continue to talk about how they lost the draft pick game.

Add us as a preferred source on Google